• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Log in

  • About
    • The GradFund Team
    • Success Stories
  • Advice
    • Blog
    • Planning When to Apply
    • Proposal Writing Advice
  • Fellowships and Grants
    • Search for Fellowships and Grants
    • SGS Managed Awards
    • SGS Competitive Awards
  • Resources
    • GradFund Self-Paced Guide to Grants and Fellowships
    • Research Development Support
    • Funding Directories
  • Questions
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Contact Us
  • Meet With Us

Make the Case That Your Project Will Contribute to Your Field

Posted on March 25, 2019 by JORIE HOFSTRA

From a funder’s perspective, your passion for your project isn’t enough. Funders want to know that you have designed a project that does more than simply exercise your own intellectual curiosity. Even when it is not explicitly stated among the priorities listed in the program solicitation or guidelines, funders typically want to support a scholar who shows that she is poised to contribute to her field. But what does this mean, and how can you identify the field-building potential of your project?

Dr. Cynthia Verba has theorized three broad types of contribution that your project could make to your field. She suggests thinking through these paradigms, keeping them in mind so you can practice identifying where the articles and books that you read would fit into this typology, and then using them to help you think through the contribution your project could make. The paradigms –described more fully in her publication “Scholarly Pursuits: A Guide to Professional Development during the Graduate Years–” are: 1. A topic that hasn’t previously been studied. If your research fits this paradigm, it is vital to show that you’re doing more than simply filling a gap. You must show that you have identified a significant absence in the scholarship in your area.

2. A topic reexamined through a new lens. Here, Dr. Verba cautions against appearing to dismiss previous research by others. Focus on how you are adding to this body of work, rather than correcting or replacing it.

3. A new case or material through which to address a topic. As noted for the first paradigm, you should be careful to show that you are not simply taking a completist approach to fill all possible gaps in knowledge. Show that the new material you have identified points in a new direction or lends an additional dimension to the existing scholarship. Once you have identified the paradigm that is the closest fit to your project—and Dr. Verba suggests that this is most likely to be the third one—the task is to convey this to your reader. This isn’t something you can accomplish in a single statement. Rather, it should be integrated into different ways throughout the proposal: in the way you describe the importance of your work in the introduction, how you define the central goals of your project, and how you situate your work in the relevant bodies of literature, for instance. Clarifying the way in which you convey your contribution to your field is one of the many areas in which our advisors can help you craft a more competitive application.

Reference:

Verba, Cynthia. 2013. “Scholarly Pursuits: A Guide to Professional Development during the Graduate Years: Eleventh Edition.” Harvard University Graduate School of Arts and Sciences. Accessed online 3/1/19 at https://gsas.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/atoms/files/Scholarly%20Pursuits_CURRENT.pdf

Filed Under: Proposal Writing Advice

Stay in Touch!

Our newsletter will keep you informed about new funding opportunities and upcoming deadlines, as well as information about GradFund services and other resources that will help you search for and apply to funding opportunities.

* indicates required





Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search Awards

Make an Appointment →

Get personalized help finding funding and writing applications

Founded in 2000, GradFund’s mission is to assist Rutgers graduate students in securing merit-based research grants and fellowships to support their graduate study and research. Read about our history and approach to working with graduate students. Learn more →

Copyright © 2025 Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, an equal opportunity, affirmative action institution. All rights reserved. Log in